Personal website of journalist Jonathan Walker

Who I Am

Jonathan Walker, Political Editor for the Birmingham Post and Birmingham Mail. Contact me at jonathan@walkerjon.com.

Where I Am

I am a lobby correspondent working from the House of Commons.

What I Do

I write local and national political stories. I also write a regular column for the Birmingham Post, a weekly diary for the Birmingham Mail and leaders for the Post. I also blog on the Post website.

(Edit: And also see MarkMedia's site for more debate).

Jo Geary has prompted a debate on her blog with a post lamenting the fact that "journalists don't know their own business".

She writes: "After all, if we don't understand how our market is created, nor how we best make money out of it, then I would argue we know little about serving it properly."

She argues that the National Union of Journalists should adopt "a pro-active policy of educating members and providing them with access to financial information on their companies".

Orson Wells as newspaper magnate Charles Foster Kane

I wrote a comment, which I re-post here (as it was really far too long to be a comment). It's partly a response to other comments from Jo's readers, which included suggestions that journalists should learn about search engine optimisation - how to get a high ranking in Google - and the usual NUJ bashing.

By the way, the profit margin on Trinity Mirror's regionals (such as the ones I work for) was 21 per cent in the last financial year, significantly down from 25.6 per cent previously, but actually pretty good by the standards of most businesses, surely?

There are two issues here. One is how the internet changes the way they do their jobs, which is basically to gather and pass on information and ideas. Jeff Jarvis' blog gives one very simple and clear example - it could now mean providing links, in some cases.

The second issue, which is separate, is how we create a business model which pays our wages.

Good journalism which makes the best use of all the media available to us (I mean that one brand, such as the newspaper I work for, uses various media, with print being one of them) does not necessarily pay the bills in today's world.

Teaching journalists about search engine optimisation and ‘social media', or improving their work in other ways, won't change that - will it?

Read more...

Journalism

One of my favourite stories of recent days didn't quite make the grade in the Birmingham Post and got chopped down to 100 words or so - and can't even be found on the website.

That may very well be the fate it deserves, but by the power of the Interweb I present it here anyway, as I liked it. The MP concerned told the House of Commons that this was "serious monkey business".

Cheeta the chimpanzee should receive an Oscar for his role in films and television shows including the Tarzan movies, according to a West Midlands MP.

Mark Pritchard wants the 76-year old animal to receive recognition in order to raise awareness of thousands of primates kept as pets.

Mr Pritchard (Con The Wrekin) launched a campaign to win an honorary Oscar for Cheeta as he presented proposals to change the law in the House of Commons.

He submitted a Bill which would make it illegal to trade primates, such as monkeys, apes or lemurs, as pets.

He said: "Keeping primates as pets is like something from Victorian times.

"It is outdated, and comes from a dark period for animal welfare in this country."

But the Victorians at least had the excuse that they did not realise that many primates were in danger of extinction in their natural habitat, he said.

Even owners who tried to take good care of primate pets were unlikely to be able to provide a suitable environment, he said.

"It is estimated that up to 3,000 primates are currently being kept as pets in the United Kingdom.

"Many are kept in cruel and cramped conditions, but by no means all of them.

"But whatever their captive conditions, these wild animals will always remain wild. These are animals that need large areas of vertical and horizontal space.

"They need certain room temperatures and humidity, long hours of natural sunlight and a varied and balanced diets."

Mr Pritchard asked MPs to back his campaign to ensure Cheeta received an Academy Award, commonly known as an Oscar, to publicise the condition of primates kept as pets.

Cheeta appeared in 12 Tarzan movies in the 1930s and 40s, and currently lives in retirement in California.

Personally I'd love a monkey as a pet. Does this make me a bad person?

Journalism

Details of an interesting new website arrive in my in-box - www.journoworld.co.uk, which aims to explain how to become a journalist and what to do once you get a job.

I like the way the first article on the topic of being a journalist is titled "dealing with newsdesks".

Hints include not telling your news editor about a story, because if they learn about something too far in advance of it actually being printed they will get bored of it, and ditch it for something newer.

Shocking stuff, although not the first time I've heard that theory.

Journalism

When I read this letter from a Daily Telegraph journalist lamenting the state of the newspaper industry (following a link from Jo Geary), I suspected they'd receive a pretty negative response.

Their complaint was that newspapers weren't interested in recruiting quality staff - and paying them accordingly - or giving them the time they needed to do a decent job of finding out what's going on and telling people what's going on.

An uncharitable interpretation of their comments would be that they were asking for more money and less work, which rarely endears you to anyone.

But they had also criticised the focus on "social media", ie blogs and stuff, and the general emphasis on the internet.

For example, they wrote:

... it's becoming all too clear at the Telegraph, whose online business plan seems to be centred on chasing hits through Google by rehashing and rewriting stories that people are already interested in. Facts are no longer the currency they used to be.

This is a bit of a no-no in the industry at the moment (far better to say you are wildly enthusiastic about social media and complain that nobody else is).

But I was still a bit surprised by this response from Justin Williams, Assistant Editor at the Telegraph Media Group, who said:

Funny thing that - writing about things that people are interested in. It would be a ... er ... radical editor who went to his bosses and said that his reporters would, henceforth, only write about things that people weren't interested in.

Well, yes, news should be interesting. I think the point being made, however, was that newspapers were basing their strategy on search engine optimisation and getting into the most-read clusters on Google News "by rehashing and rewriting stories" that are already out there.

Read more...

Journalism

Strange day at the office. A colleague on another local paper was tasked with verifying a report their newspaper had received, from someone claiming to be a Downing Street press officer, that a Minister had resigned.

The MP in question (not David Cairns, the Scottish Office Minister who actually has resigned) was overseas and unavailable, so my colleague was reduced to phoning Downing Street and the relevant Government department to try to find out what was going on.

She collared the MP's researcher on the House of Commons terrace. I'm told the researcher was frantic, because she had been contacted by numerous journalists but had no idea what was happening.

My poor colleague was under extra pressure from journalists like me, who had not only started making our own inquires but were trying to get her to tell us what she knew (as she worked for the MP's local paper, she probably had the best chance of finding out).

Eventually, she managed to track down the press officer who had phoned her paper - except that he denied making the call, and actually now worked in the Cabinet Office, not Downing Street.

My colleague got the press officer to phone her newsdesk, so the news editor could confirm the voice was different.

The original tip-off had been a fake, but it clearly came from someone who knew the names of Downing Street press officers (or at least, of people who worked there recently), which takes a bit of inside knowledge or digging.

I'm not sure what the moral of the tale is, except that nobody knows what's going to happen next at Westminster.

Apologies for not giving names, but I don't want to repeat false rumours about Ministers even with the words "it wasn't true" in big letters.

Journalism

More Articles...

Page 10 of 15

10

Twitter Feed

jonwalker121's avatar
Jonathan Walker jonwalker121
  • bio:
    Political Editor Birmingham Post and Mail
  • location:
    London
  • updates:
    739
  • followers:
    478
  • following:
    443
Loading...

Last 4 tweets from jonwalker121:

People talking about '#birminghamuk':

Get News

Brothers In Arms

Latest Comments

Make an RSS Feed for your Favourite Journalist
Thanks for sharing that Murray. Will, I can't rea...

Make an RSS Feed for your Favourite Journalist
A great tip there! Thanks Jonathan! Question is: w...

Make an RSS Feed for your Favourite Journalist
Hi Jonathan - a similar approach can also be usefu...

Blog Aggregator for Birmingham
Jon, thanks for your comment and you're probably r...

Blog Aggregator for Birmingham
I have seen Jon's news wire, which not only does w...

Blog Aggregator for Birmingham
Hi Have you checked out Jon Bounds' hyperlocal new...

Birmingham News

News

Post Column

Opinion

My weekly column in the Birmingham Post.

Mail Diary

Diary

My weekly diary in the Birmingham Mail.

Post Blog

Blog

My Birmingham Post blog.

Some Ideas

RSS Me

Cloud Search